•  

Comment Results

Review Name Created Custom Fields Content
HD-DEN-7395-1 08 Apr 2021

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

HD-DEN-8030-1 25 Jun 2021

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

DG-DEN-5963-1 07 Apr 2021

Align the defines. Doxygen comment can be moved up one line using ///.

HD-DEN-7395-1 13 Apr 2021

Typecasting the variables is not needed here. The macro typecasts them.

UI-DEN-7135-1 09 Apr 2021

You are half right.
The intention is not to force to have always a key or a value since the use case might be different in various situations.
But a good catch that in our specific case if the value(image) is empty qml was complaining about not finding the image which fixed in:
InstructionView.qml:~97

HD-DEN-11980-1 17 Feb 2022

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

UI-DEN-7135-1 10 Apr 2021

RESOLVED.

HD-DEN-9906-1 15 Nov 2021

I wasn't sure what flow sensor "response" registers were - moot now that sensors are gone.
Still unsure what to do with processor/pc error counts - will resolve this in a future branch.

HD-DEN-9906-1 15 Nov 2021

I adjusted spaces "before" the equal sign.

HD-DEN-9906-1 15 Nov 2021

Removed.

HD-DEN-7395-1 12 Apr 2021

I don't think we should have state as overrideable. Here, you are only looking at non-override version of state, so override would not have any impact anyway.
You could have Dialin function force a transition to a given state - I think that would be useful from testing perspective. But transition would need to be more than just setting state - e.g. we would need to put sensor in zero state via FPGA if we wanted to go to the zero state in your state machine.

HD-DEN-7395-1 11 Apr 2021

I imagine this state should look for self-test to pass (indicate a blood leak) within some time period and then we would tell FPGA to put sensor in normal state and set your state machine to normal state. Fault if times out.

HD-DEN-7395-1 11 Apr 2021

initBloodLeak() was already called from main in sys_main.c. I don't think we need to keep calling it here.
How do we get out of INIT state?

HD-DEN-7395-1 09 Apr 2021

So you combined the published data into one message in the publish function above which is correct. But these overrides must be separate. You should only override one thing at a time, so overrides were ok as it was before.

DIALIN-DEN-7135-1 01 Apr 2021

Why not align all of them then?

DIALIN-DEN-7135-1 01 Apr 2021

Either remove commented lines or add TODO in comment.

HD-DEN-9906-1 15 Nov 2021

Done.

DIALIN-DEN-7135-1 13 Apr 2021

RESOLVED.

DIALIN-DEN-7135-1 01 Apr 2021

Remove extra line.

UI-DEN-7044-1 07 Apr 2021

Please move it to line 139

DG-DEN-5963-1 14 Apr 2021

This enum has been deleted.

DG-DEN-5963-1 08 Apr 2021

Align comment.

HD-DEN-9906-1 15 Nov 2021

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

HD-DEN-9906-1 15 Nov 2021

Some of local variables are not used in this function, consider removing them.

DG-DEN-9906-1 15 Nov 2021

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

HD-DEN-11098-1 19 Nov 2021

I believe reservoir 2 is used.

static PRE_TREATMENT_RESERVOIR_MGMT_STATE_T handlePreTreatmentReservoirMgmtStartState( void )
{
PRE_TREATMENT_RESERVOIR_MGMT_STATE_T state = PRE_TREATMENT_RESERVOIR_MGMT_START_STATE;

if ( TRUE == fillReservoirOneStartRequested )

Unknown macro: { fillReservoirOneStartRequested = FALSE; state = PRE_TREATMENT_RESERVOIR_MGMT_DRAIN_CMD_STATE; cmdSetDGActiveReservoir( DG_RESERVOIR_2 ); }


return state;
}

UI-DEN-10602-1 29 Nov 2021

Looks like the rest of this function is dead code. Why are we returning here?

UI-DEN-10602-1 29 Nov 2021

RESOLVED.

HD-DEN-11114-1 29 Nov 2021

Done.

HD-DEN-11098-1 02 Dec 2021

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

HD-DEN-11098-1 18 Nov 2021

Dialyzer is spelled with a "z" not "s".

HD-DEN-11114-1 02 Dec 2021

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

HD-DEN-11114-1 02 Dec 2021

Done.

UI-DEN-10205-1 09 Dec 2021

RESOLVED.

HD-DEN-11098-1 13 Dec 2021

Fixed.

UI-DEN-10602-1 13 Dec 2021

that is fine because...

HD-DEN-11098-1 13 Dec 2021

Replaced "loadcellSteadyVolumeStartTime" with "steadyVolumeSamplingStartTime"

DIALIN-DEN-10602-2 15 Dec 2021

This function header is missing type hinting

UI-DEN-7135-1 09 Apr 2021

I was hoping the same but in our setting, the order is so important but QSettings doesn't guaranty the reading order and will reorder the read key, value pairs.
So I had to implement our own reader.
For the groups, it doesn't matter much but for the key, values which are going to be the instruction pair of title, image the order is so important.
please don't confuse that the designated key and values are always correct but the lines are not in correct order.

UI-DEN-7135-1 09 Apr 2021

If needed, sure.
Every commit has to be reviewed otherwise the bamboo scripts will not let the build happen.

HD-DEN-9906-1 15 Nov 2021

Our coding standard does not require MISRA compliance and I don't think our coding standard includes this if else rule.
If you think it should be added to our standard, let's discuss.

UI-DEN-7135-1 09 Apr 2021

done

DIALIN-DEN-7135-1 11 Apr 2021

I didn't want to change all the others to be aligned since it makes it confusing that what was actually required for the content of the change.
If needed let me know to make those two to be like the others.

DG-DEN-5963-1 22 Mar 2021

This doesn't look like a complete list of possible status. What are these used for?

HD-DEN-11980-1 16 Feb 2022

Fixed. Thanks!

DG-DEN-5963-1 12 Apr 2021

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

DG-DEN-8030-1 16 Jun 2021

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

HD-DEN-7395-1 12 Apr 2021

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

HD-DEN-7395-1 11 Apr 2021

A break is needed here.

HD-DEN-7395-1 12 Apr 2021

Addressed.