•  

Comment Results

Review Name Created Custom Fields Content
HD-SPR3-1 10 Oct 2019

Suggest using variable different than l. l might be confused with 1 ("one")

HD-SPR3-1 14 Oct 2019

Addressed in code-walkthrough.

HD-SPR3-1 10 Oct 2019

Label to something that indicates is temp

HD-SPR3-1 14 Oct 2019

Used build switch.

HD-SPR3-1 10 Oct 2019

Please use parenthesis

HD-SPR3-1 14 Oct 2019

Addressed in code-walkthrough.

HD-SPR3-1 10 Oct 2019

Please use parenthesis

HD-SPR3-1 14 Oct 2019

Addressed in code-walkthrough.

HD-SPR3-1 10 Oct 2019

Define 1 as confirmed and 0 as rejected. Create #define variables or use true or false.

HD-SPR3-1 14 Oct 2019

Used build switch.

HD-SPR3-1 17 Oct 2019

Addressed in code walk-through.

HD-SPR3-1 17 Oct 2019

Don't we have a max, min macro?

HD-SPR4-1 24 Oct 2019

Make the ? operator a macro to make it more readable

HD-SPR4-1 24 Oct 2019

Not clear what is the purpose of DATA_DECL

HD-SPR3-1 17 Oct 2019

inactiveBuffer = !activeBuffer isn't more readable?

HD-SPR3-1 17 Oct 2019

Isn't copyFromCommBuffer a clearer name for this function?

HD-SPR3-1 17 Oct 2019

Same comment as before

HD-SPR4-1 24 Oct 2019

currentLampPattern should be a local variable and it is OK to use it. Using a function add unnecessary extra lower level step. If a function is used, should be for modules outside this one.

HD-SPR3-1 17 Oct 2019

I prefer as is.

HD-SPR4-1 24 Oct 2019

This pattern is confusing. Not very clear what is meant to do

HD-DEN-431-1 06 Jan 2020

Done!

HD-SPR3-1 17 Oct 2019

No need for srcPtr pointer... data can be use directly

UI-DEN-625-1 25 Oct 2019

RESOLVED.

UI-DEN-625-1 25 Oct 2019

RESOLVED.

HD-SPR3-1 18 Oct 2019

RESOLVED IN CODE WALKTHROUGH

HD-SPR3-1 18 Oct 2019

RESOLVED IN CODE WALKTHROUGH

UI-DEN-626-1 28 Oct 2019

seems like when I replied the emails were not working
Just as a reminder.

HD-SPR3-1 17 Oct 2019

That would have worked too. Since I've got unit and integration test cases looking for this name, I'd prefer not to change it.

HD-SPR3-1 17 Oct 2019

I prefer it this way.

HD-SPR3-1 17 Oct 2019

blank line after dataPtr. for readability

HD-SPR3-1 17 Oct 2019

I'm not sure I understand this issue. There is a variable that indicates the active buffer for each buffer. I am not passing the active buffer - I'm passing the buffer of interest and this function is using the active buffer variable to manage it internally as you say.

HD-DEN-759-1 14 Nov 2019

Here it is taking value "4".

UI-DEN-1090-1 19 Dec 2019

Same here.

HD-DEN-759-1 14 Nov 2019

Value "8", which is ...?

HD-SPR3-1 18 Oct 2019

RESOLVED IN CODE WALKTHROUGH

HD-SPR3-1 17 Oct 2019

Shouldn't we test if this is done by hardware... In other words, if I pull a queue of messages. Doesn't the hardware figure it out what to send first?

HD-SPR3-1 17 Oct 2019

I have the MESSAGE_T type as our denali message (minus the CRC) and I have the MESSAGE_WRAPPER_T as a MESSAGE_T with a CRC wrapped in. This makes it easier to implement the CRC check (calc CRC for the message only) and then throw away the wrapper (CRC) after it checks out.

HD-SPR3-1 17 Oct 2019

Same response.

HD-SPR3-1 17 Oct 2019

The comment explains. I haven't implemented the transmitter idle check yet - so I'm assuming it is idle for now (as it generally would be).

HD-SPR3-1 17 Oct 2019

Hardware will only handle which packet wins when 2 or more nodes are trying to send a packet at the same time. For each node (sub-system), software still needs to decide which packet it wants to send next.

HD-SPR3-1 17 Oct 2019

Why?

HD-SPR3-1 18 Oct 2019

RESOLVED IN CODE WALKTHROUGH

HD-SPR3-1 17 Oct 2019

I will add more comment lines instead of blank lines. See HD-SPR4-1 review for fix.

HD-SPR3-1 17 Oct 2019

I used the MIN macro. See fix in the HD-SPR4-1 review.

HD-SPR3-1 17 Oct 2019

Agreed. See HD-SPR4-1 review for fix.

HD-MASTER-1 04 Oct 2019

RESOLVED.

HD-SPR3-1 17 Oct 2019

blank line after blankMessageInWrapper for readability

HD-SPR3-1 17 Oct 2019

This if statement makes no sense

HD-SPR3-1 18 Oct 2019

RESOLVED IN CODE WALKTHROUGH

HD-SPR3-1 17 Oct 2019

I couldn't find the definition of MESSAGE_WRAPPER_T... Words like wrapper is too generic. Are this denali message. Let's give name similar to our documentation.