•  

Comment Results

Review Name Created Custom Fields Content
UI-DEN-4690-2-1 30 Sep 2020

I have no plan.
If it requires any new feature/improvement etc then I'll start using classes next time I'm getting into that code.

UI-DEN-3605-4 06 Oct 2020

It is now deleted

DIALIN-DEN-4308-1 30 Sep 2020

RESOLVED.

DIALIN-DEN-4308-1 30 Sep 2020

During testing, I have been commenting and uncommenting code to test different parts of code. Since this is in tests, does that really matter?

UI-DEN-3605-4 30 Sep 2020

This function is not a test function its a helper function to a test function

DG-DEN-3504-1 02 Nov 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

DIALIN-DEN-4640-1 06 Oct 2020

I think it was a little out of date with UF change messaging. Obsolete.

UI-DEN-3605-4 30 Sep 2020

make the tst_view your class friend.
so it will have access to the private members of your class.
Please read the existing code thoroughly and see how some issues have been solved and please do not reinvent the wheel.

"********* I must emphasize that making a class a friend of the other is only allowed for test classes. *********"
And also please do these tests in SquishQt, not in C++, look at the next commit.

UI-DEN-3605-4 08 Sep 2020

Why these parameters don't match with our "Message List" document?
Not even the order but also the types?
It's really hard to follow!

UI-DEN-3605-4 30 Sep 2020

Fine then,
RESOLVED

DG-DEN-3504-1 02 Nov 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

DG-DEN-3504-1 02 Nov 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

UI-DEN-3605-4 06 Oct 2020

Done - they are renamed and the extension has been removed. Will post the update soon

UI-DEN-3605-4 06 Oct 2020

Please put a short description of your component and explain what it does and where it can be used.
Since it is a specific or compound component and is not a general component like a just a Slider or Progressbar, it helps to understand the use case of the component.

UI-DEN-3605-4 06 Oct 2020

Please put a short description of your component and explain what it does and where it can be used.
Since it is a specific or compound component and is not a general component like a just a Slider or Progressbar, it helps to understand the use case of the component.

UI-DEN-4598-1 02 Nov 2020

Done

UI-DEN-3605-4 07 Oct 2020

RESOLVED

UI-DEN-4964-1 13 Oct 2020

Since RefUFVol and MeasUFVol are in liters, can we show these with 3 decimal places so we can infer mL?

UI-DEN-4690-2-1 30 Sep 2020

"*** Off the subject ***"
I don't have any plans for that.
It was an effort to feel the gap of not having the corresponding FW code at that moment.
If it happens again will consider improving the code otherwise we need to consolidate with our manager for priorities/planning.

UI-DEN-4690-1 07 Oct 2020

I think if it's not false (false if the vData of type QByteArray is not sufficient regarding vAction) then it would be true, right ?!

DIALIN-DEN-4690-1 07 Oct 2020

"*** Off the subject ***"
This code review is about the documentation, not the code change.
There is no implementation and unit testing associated with this story.

TESTSUITES-DEN-3724-1 07 Oct 2020

Why this is added?
The unit test for that feature was working and all the tests and coverage passed.
Why it has been modified?
Please remove it.

UI-DEN-4964-1 13 Oct 2020

If .toFixed(2) indicates that we want to display 2 decimal places, these first 6 values are in gravities - likely between -1 and +1 - and so I'd like to see these with 3 decimal places.

DIALIN-DEN-4856-1 12 Oct 2020

should we keep the copyright?

DG-DEN-3504-1 07 Oct 2020

Removed and used lowest weight instead.

UI-DEN-3605-4 28 Aug 2020

Remove 2 extra lines.

DIALIN-DEN-3875-1 28 Aug 2020

Hey Peter,
You're right I removed them to easier do the merge.
Since the task DEN-4690: Doxygenization has been changed to story and there is a code review sub-task for that, let's address all the documentation in that stoy.

UI-DEN-3605-4 28 Aug 2020

Remove 2 extra lines.

DIALIN-DEN-3875-1 28 Aug 2020

Hey Peter,
You're right I removed them to easier do the merge.
Since the task DEN-4690: Doxygenization has been changed to story and there is a code review sub-task for that, let's address all the documentation in that stoy.

HD-DEN-5053-1 30 Sep 2020

RESOLVED IN CODE WALKTRHOUGH

DIALIN-DEN-4308-1 30 Sep 2020

Please make the handler private (e.g. _handler instead of handler)

DIALIN-DEN-4308-1 29 Sep 2020

Shouldn't there be a set of the properties for each valve?

UI-DEN-4690-1 09 Sep 2020

RESOLVED.

UI-DEN-4690-1 09 Sep 2020

RESOLVED.

UI-DEN-3605-4 05 Oct 2020

RESOLVED

DIALIN-DEN-4211-1 09 Sep 2020

RESOLVED.

DIALIN-DEN-4169-1 09 Sep 2020

Done.

HD-DEN-7395-1 12 Apr 2021

Addressed.

DG-DEN-5963-1 03 Apr 2021

Done.

DIALIN-DEN-4640-1 05 Oct 2020

Done.

HD-DEN-4308-3 05 Oct 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

DIALIN-DEN-3504-1 02 Nov 2020

These two have the same ID

HD-DEN-4211-1 09 Sep 2020

This is from Dara's HD valves branch. I pulled his FPGA module because he did the last update for register alignment with latest FPGA version, but now that I'm trying to wrap up dev testing, I don't want to duplicate effort to test these functions. All I really needed from the pull was the register map - should have deleted these right after the pull.

HD-DEN-4211-1 09 Sep 2020

Why did get this section deleted?

HD-DEN-4308-3 22 Sep 2020

Maybe elaborate a little more on comments. For instance, is this edge detection counter really couting edges? I suspect not.

DG-DEN-3504-1 02 Nov 2020

Need a space here.

HD-DEN-4640-1 05 Oct 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

HD-DEN-4640-1 05 Oct 2020

Add extra line before if.

DIALIN-DEN-4308-1 05 Oct 2020

Last ")" comes after vPWM)).

UI-DEN-3605-4 06 Oct 2020

Done, see the other Variables.qml to the left. http://dvm-linux02:8060/cru/#UI-DEN-3605-4CFR-16980