•  

Comment Results

Review Name Created Custom Fields Content
UI-DEN-3605-4 28 Aug 2020

Done

HD-DEN-4308-3 05 Oct 2020

Done

DIALIN-DEN-3875-1 28 Aug 2020

RESOLVED

UI-DEN-4690-1 14 Oct 2020

RESOLVED.

HD-DEN-4211-1 28 Aug 2020

Anything messaging we want to do when SW fault?

HD-DEN-7117-1 06 Apr 2021

Done.

UI-DEN-3605-4 05 Oct 2020

It has been done on the other comments.
RESOLVED

UI-DEN-3605-4 05 Oct 2020

Now it's part of the code review.
RESOLVED

UI-DEN-4598-1 01 Nov 2020

These are all the same how come they have different comments?

UI-DEN-3605-4 05 Oct 2020

RESOLVED

HD-DEN-4211-1 28 Aug 2020

So this would indicate we're in an invalid state for treatment parameters mode which shouldn't be possible unless memory was corrupted (stack overflow or buffer overflow, ...). So we will trigger a s/w fault (generic something bad happened in s/w fault) with supporting data of 1) a unique # (enum) to indicate this s/w fault is an invalid treatment parameters mode state and 2) what was the invalid state ID that s/w saw. All of that will be logged by UI. This is all part of the TODO which I have addressed in next commit.

UI-DEN-4964-1 16 Dec 2020

RESOLVED

HD-DEN-4308-3 22 Sep 2020

Add more to comment. This is the 18th pin on HET port 1 that we're re-purposing for GPIO to actuate the air trap valve?

HD-DEN-4308-3 05 Oct 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

HD-DEN-4308-3 28 Sep 2020

Done

HD-DEN-4308-3 05 Oct 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

UI-DEN-4690-2-1 30 Sep 2020

Should all files under utility be renamed as well?

UI-DEN-3605-4 30 Sep 2020

Why didn't use the standard predefined PROPERY?
This way it's not like the other implementation.
We don't use set_ and/or get_ .

UI-DEN-4690-2-1 30 Sep 2020

Better to fix it now then never

UI-DEN-4690-1 09 Sep 2020

This filename is not CamelCase

UI-DEN-4690-1 30 Sep 2020

The code documentation is still missing:
http://192.168.10.132:8060/cru/UI-DEN-4690-2-1#CFR-18520

DIALIN-DEN-4308-1 30 Sep 2020

RESOLVED.

DIALIN-DEN-4308-1 28 Sep 2020

Align with left "(".

DIALIN-DEN-4308-1 28 Sep 2020

Remove extra line.

DIALIN-DEN-4308-1 28 Sep 2020

Align with left "(".

DG-DEN-3504-1 07 Oct 2020

Removed. Used lowest weight to detect unchanged weight.

DIALIN-DEN-4690-1 09 Sep 2020

Description is missing for the parameters here and many of the other functions

UI-DEN-4690-1 09 Sep 2020

Is quitThread() unused?

How do you know, or what led you to realize that application termination isn't correctly done in coco?
How did you test that it works perfectly fine?

UI-DEN-3605-4 30 Sep 2020

Do not agree with this delay.
Your implementation should not depend on a wait and if you that important to make sure it is done you need to have signal in your class to emit when write or read is done.
Also you are using the static method and that function is pauseing the current thread I believe using the static method will pause the entire test.
This is not a good test.
Please also look at the link below:
https://doc.qt.io/qt-5/qthread.html#msleep

UI-DEN-4690-2-1 14 Oct 2020

Fair, not related to story.

RESOLVED.

UI-DEN-3605-4 30 Sep 2020

It's necessary for adding delays since the file writer class runs in a separate thread. To check that a file was written, we wait for more than enough time before checking the file was written properly.

UI-DEN-4690-2-1 30 Sep 2020

It's preferred to not use a global variable unless absolutely necessary

UI-DEN-3605-4 14 Oct 2020

RESOLVED

UI-DEN-3605-4 30 Sep 2020

I believe it was better to do it like the other classes and use SquishQt to test the whole stack of MVC and if that didn't work cover more in here with simple small functions.
The test functions are so big and have so many compare in just one function.
This is not the correct way of testing.

UI-DEN-3605-4 28 Aug 2020

Remove extra line.

UI-DEN-3605-4 28 Aug 2020

Remove 2 extra lines.

HD-DEN-4211-1 28 Aug 2020

This was an old idea I'd had about something we might want Dialin to be able to do, but seeing how Dialin has evolved it's clear we will not be doing this.

UI-DEN-3605-4 28 Aug 2020

Remove extra line.

DIALIN-DEN-4308-1 30 Sep 2020

Any reason to keep this?

DIALIN-DEN-3875-1 28 Aug 2020

Hey Peter,
You're right I removed them to easier do the merge.
Since the task DEN-4690: Doxygenization has been changed to story and there is a code review sub-task for that, let's address all the documentation in that stoy.

HD-DEN-13460-2 22 Sep 2022

Done.

UI-DEN-3605-4 28 Aug 2020

Done

HD-DEN-4308-3 05 Oct 2020

Done

UI-DEN-4690-1 09 Sep 2020

RESOLVED.

UI-DEN-3605-4 28 Aug 2020

RESOLVED.

HD-DEN-4308-3 05 Oct 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

UI-DEN-3605-4 08 Sep 2020

Please from now on use Camel Case for file names.
So it should be MTreatmentParameters(.h , .cpp)

HD-DEN-4308-3 22 Sep 2020

Can we elaborate on direction in comments? Is clockwise moving towards energized edge?

UI-DEN-3605-4 05 Oct 2020

RESOLVED.

HD-DEN-4308-3 28 Sep 2020

Done