•  

Comment Results

Review Name Created Custom Fields Content
DG-DEN-3421-1 10 Aug 2020

Where is this target speed being set? Do you even have a target speed in closed loop delta pressure mode? drainPumpDAC value should be set in the set delta pressure function. Only drainPumpDACSet should be set here.

DG-DEN-3421-1 11 Aug 2020

And put it in common.h in fwcommon.

DG-DEN-13598-2 22 Sep 2022

Removed test code and comment at end of line.

DG-DEN-3421-1 11 Aug 2020

Spec'd in HDD. Just needs to be done and added to Drain Pump broadcast data.

DG-DEN-4169-1 31 Jul 2020

Done. Without the sense of time, it is easier to make mistakes. The intention here is 5 seconds rather than 50 seconds.

DG-DEN-4169-1 31 Jul 2020

Clearing should probably be a longer persistence than triggering threshold. Currently both are 50 sec. I think that's too long for triggering. Maybe ok for clearing.

DG-DEN-4169-1 31 Jul 2020

Try to give a sense of time for this. I think Modes are calling the check function so that's on the General Task so that's every 50ms x 1000 = 50 seconds. I usually define these types of things as a # of ms divided by the appropriate task interval (in ms).

DG-DEN-3421-1 12 Aug 2020

Done

DG-DEN-3421-1 12 Aug 2020

I am still waiting to finalize the #defines. Once they are all done, I usually align all of them to the longest #define

UI-DEN-4438-1 23 Aug 2020

done

HD-DEN-4641-1 30 Nov 2020

Fixed.

DG-DEN-4217-1 11 Aug 2020

All of these flags are for DEBUG build only (not release) and most are not see by Vectorcast either - so for code review purposes it doesn't really matter what the last DEBUG build configuration was.

UI-DEN-4860-BLE-1 14 Jan 2021

Oh I see.
RESOLVED

UI-DEN-4438-1 25 Aug 2020

File name must use camelCase.

DG-DEN-3421-1 12 Aug 2020

Yes, they are all before the EOF and #endif

UI-DEN-4438-1 25 Aug 2020

File name must use camelCase.

DG-DEN-3421-1 13 Aug 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

UI-DEN-4438-1 25 Aug 2020

File name must use camelCase.

DG-DEN-3421-1 13 Aug 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

DG-DEN-3421-1 10 Aug 2020

This should be done in "Set" function above. And assigned to the non "Set" variable. Then, here we would set roPumpPWMDutyCyclePctSet = roPumpPWMDutyCyclePct;

DG-DEN-4217-1 11 Aug 2020

Are these flags enabled as intention?

DG-DEN-4217-1 12 Aug 2020

Release builds (i.e. Bamboo) will not have any of these build switches defined. As we get closer to DVT, we should be able to get rid of most of these debug build switches, but they will never interfere with a release build.

DG-DEN-4217-1 12 Aug 2020

Done

DG-DEN-4217-1 12 Aug 2020

Done

UI-DEN-4438-1 25 Aug 2020

File name must use camelCase.

UI-DEN-3253-1 11 Jun 2020

Done

DG-DEN-4217-1 12 Aug 2020

1) Remove extra line;
2) Doxygen /*@}/ missing.

UI-DEN-3149-1 11 Jun 2020

explained in another comment.

DG-DEN-4217-1 12 Aug 2020

1) Remove extra line;
2) Missing the Doxygen /*@}/ at eof.

UI-DEN-3149-1 11 Jun 2020

Just a separator from the other part of the codes to find that section easier.

DG-DEN-3421-1 12 Aug 2020

Remove "_" after LPM

DG-DEN-3922-1 23 Jul 2020

Probably a merge error. Added back.

UI-DEN-3253-1 26 Jun 2020

Please do not remove the comments with // SquishQt.
It means it has been added to be used in SquishQt.
And It shows that if we change it our unit tests in SquishQt is not working anymore since it is using this object name to identify the object properly.

UI-DEN-3875-1 20 Aug 2020

done

HD-DEN-7395-1 12 Apr 2021

Good catch, addressed.

DG-DEN-3421-1 12 Aug 2020

One liner

UI-DEN-3875-1 20 Aug 2020

done

DG-DEN-3421-1 12 Aug 2020

Done

UI-DEN-3253-1 26 Jun 2020

Whether it is your code or anybody else's code, it doesn't matter, this way of writing code is simply off standard and unprecedented, frankly. It also does not matter whether Peter or anybody else approved it or not, all that matters is that it is against the standard.

UI-DEN-3253-1 26 Jun 2020

It seems Jira is doing its best to confuse the user with this whole slider of commits and not showing the comments in order and sometimes even hiding comments.
I totally don't understand the purpose of these confusing features.
Source versioning is so simple and don't need to be complicated by this unnecessary features.

So please forgive me if because of this <not a good adjective> features I put some comments which are irrelevant.
Thanks,

HD-DEN-15306-3 02 Jun 2023

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

DG-DEN-4169-1 31 Jul 2020

The windowed count should be used for FPGA error. For this one, the time is 40 ms (4 read and 10 ms per read) of unchanged read count.

DG-DEN-4169-1 31 Jul 2020

Move all arguments and align them with the left "(" of start of argument list.

HD-DEN-4640-1 05 Oct 2020

Done.

DG-DEN-5846-1 30 Nov 2020

This was due to an FPGA bug. It has been fixed and I will test it.

DG-DEN-13598-2 22 Sep 2022

Done.

UI-DEN-4438-1 24 Aug 2020

extra line removed.
This is the namespace brace and the namespaces braces are not indenting the code. so are at the same column as class brace in this case.

DG-DEN-13598-2 22 Sep 2022

Removed.

UI-DEN-3605-4 05 Oct 2020

RESOLVED

UI-DEN-3605-4 28 Aug 2020

RESOLVED.