•  

Comment Results

Review Name Created Custom Fields Content
UI-DEN-4438-1 25 Aug 2020

Absolutely,
I'm doing it incrementally and slowly to not to make the code reviews harder and confusing git.
I did for so many and this file will get its turn soon.

UI-DEN-3605-4 05 Oct 2020

typedef Model::TreatmentParameters::Data TreatmentData;
to
typedef Model::MTreatmentParameters::Data TreatmentParametersData;

UI-DEN-4438-1 25 Aug 2020

Absolutely,
I'm doing it incrementally and slowly to not to make the code reviews harder and confusing git.
I did for so many and this file will get its turn soon.

DIALIN-DEN-4438-1 23 Aug 2020

I have a screen capture that I can't attach here and put in X:\Users\PemanM.
As I explained in the image file, I don't quit understand how Squish is managing the last line.
Now I removed extra it shows no empty line at the EOF but I see there is one, prior to that it was showing one but was actually two.
Squish and Jira have different view.
external editor is showing one empty line though.

UI-DEN-3605-4 01 Sep 2020

RESOLVED.

DG-DEN-4322-1 25 Aug 2020

I've been putting 2 blank lines above and below this comment to emphasize we're moving to Dialin support functions.

HD-DEN-5053-1 23 Sep 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

HD-DEN-4308-3 22 Sep 2020

Should A/B/C positions be cast to S16?

HD-DEN-4308-3 01 Sep 2020

I was using the same public structure variable in valves.h. Now I define local variables for both.

UI-DEN-3605-4 15 Sep 2020

This code review was created on August 25.
The design changes with MAbstract and MModel were merged to master on August 31st.
Our process now discourages merging code between development branches, so the create treatment implementation doesn't incorporate the design changes that were first merged to master on August 31st.
As per our convesation yesterday, the work to subclass MAbstract and MModel, which will change the lines you're asking about, is going to be tracked in this ticket next sprint. http://dvm-linux02:8080/browse/DEN-4981

UI-DEN-3605-4 14 Sep 2020

As per our conversation today, due to the design changes with MAbstract.h and MModel.h that were merged to master on Aug. 31st, the create treatment models will be updated to subclass these parent classes.
This work is going to be tracked in this ticket: http://dvm-linux02:8080/browse/DEN-4981

LEAHI-DD-FIRMWARE-LDT-3344-1 11 Feb 2026

Is return value in °C? U32 is pretty low resolution for a temperature.

UI-DEN-3605-4 14 Sep 2020

Done, see 5387db3

UI-DEN-3605-4 05 Oct 2020

In the Qt docs, there's an example I probably based this on:
https://doc.qt.io/qt-5.12/qtquick-customitems-scrollbar-main-qml.html

UI-DEN-3605-4 14 Sep 2020

RESOLVED.

UI-DEN-3605-4 05 Oct 2020

will be reviewed later on the assigned code review.
RESOLVED

HD-DEN-4308-3 22 Sep 2020

Done

HD-DEN-4308-3 22 Sep 2020

I think we should cap all of these target position assignments. 15,000 counts is intended to over-reach commanded position. So just blindly adding/subtracting 15,000 from current position is not what we want. If current position +/- the big step is beyond our commanded position, we just want to set our target to the commanded position. Only if target is less than commanded position do we want to take the entire step.

HD-DEN-4308-3 22 Sep 2020

I uncommented the for loop.

UI-DEN-3605-4 30 Sep 2020

Missing translations.
Please apply to all the other occurrences, there are so many on this page, I don't put comment for all.

HD-DEN-4308-3 22 Sep 2020

Done

HD-DEN-4308-3 22 Sep 2020

Blank line between declarations and code in any scope.

HD-DEN-4308-3 22 Sep 2020

I think you should reverse the order of this subtraction and then remove the abs() in the condition below (like you did in FindEnergizedEdge above).

UI-DEN-3605-4 05 Oct 2020

will be reviewed later on the assigned code review.
RESOLVED

HD-DEN-5053-1 22 Sep 2020

Done.

HD-DEN-4308-3 23 Sep 2020

They are already S16 in the publish structure.

UI-DEN-3605-4 05 Oct 2020

Removed so,
RESOLVED.

HD-DEN-4308-3 23 Sep 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

DIALIN-DEN-4640-1 05 Oct 2020

Realign everything

HD-DEN-4308-3 23 Sep 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

HD-DEN-4308-3 23 Sep 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

UI-DEN-4690-2-1 06 Oct 2020

RESOLVED.

HD-DEN-4308-3 23 Sep 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

UI-DEN-3605-4 06 Oct 2020

Modification has been made. Will follow up on the changed code.
RESOLVED

UI-DEN-3605-4 30 Sep 2020

http://192.168.10.132:8060/cru/UI-DEN-3605-4#c5093

UI-DEN-3605-4 06 Oct 2020

RESOLVED

DIALIN-DEN-4690-1 06 Oct 2020

Thanks Peman for clarification.
As discussed with Peter, updated the docstrings.

DIALIN-DEN-4308-1 05 Oct 2020

Can't we just range check vlv_ID instead of using try?

UI-DEN-4690-2-1 05 Oct 2020

"*** Off the subject ***"
AGAIN,
I don't understand what is the relevance of the comment to the Story and which part of the code this comment is referring to?

DIALIN-DEN-4690-1 14 Oct 2020

RESOLVED

UI-DEN-4690-1 07 Oct 2020

return type is missing

UI-DEN-3605-4 15 Oct 2020

RESOLVED
Will be reviewed in later stories.

DG-DEN-5855-1 10 Dec 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

UI-DEN-4438-1 25 Aug 2020

Absolutely,
I'm doing it incrementally and slowly to not to make the code reviews harder and confusing git.
I did for so many and this file will get its turn soon.

HD-DEN-4308-3 02 Sep 2020

Fixed the algorithm.

UI-DEN-4438-1 25 Aug 2020

Absolutely,
I'm doing it incrementally and slowly to not to make the code reviews harder and confusing git.
I did for so many and this file will get its turn soon.

DG-DEN-4322-1 26 Aug 2020

Dara Navaei Can you please respond to this change?

UI-DEN-3605-4 30 Sep 2020

Same comment as :
http://192.168.10.132:8060/cru/UI-DEN-3605-4#c5093

HD-DEN-4308-3 04 Sep 2020

Done

DIALIN-DEN-4308-1 02 Oct 2020

RESOLVED