•  

Comment Results

Review Name Created Custom Fields Content
DIALIN-DEN-4690-1 14 Oct 2020

RESOLVED

HD-DEN-4641-1 01 Dec 2020

In that case, the given mode is illegal and no action is taken and result is returned FALSE. Dialin will see the FALSE return and know it was unsuccessful.

UI-DEN-4690-1 14 Oct 2020

RESOLVED.

UI-DEN-4598-1 03 Nov 2020

waitForObjectExists wasn't using the timeout of 200 ms set in config.xml.
I've updated the test use waitForObject which waits until the component is visible before clicking, so the delays are not needed and are now removed

HD-DEN-4640-1 14 Oct 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

UI-DEN-4690-1 14 Oct 2020

RESOLVED.

UI-DEN-4690-1 30 Sep 2020

This review has so many files and is quite monumental.
It would be much easier to review if there were fewer changes.
What are the list of features that are covered in this review? It seems like it's not just doxygenization

UI-DEN-4598-1 03 Nov 2020

It has been removed: http://dvm-linux02:8060/cru/#UI-DEN-4598-1CFR-19816

UI-DEN-3605-4 14 Oct 2020

RESOLVED

UI-DEN-4598-1 03 Nov 2020

Done

TESTSUITES-DEN-3724-1 14 Oct 2020

Done

TESTSUITES-DEN-3724-1 14 Oct 2020

Done

HD-DEN-5053-1 15 Oct 2020

Function name and description are not matched.

DIALIN-DEN-5283-1 19 Oct 2020

Remove extra lines (all)

UI-DEN-4598-1 03 Nov 2020

Done

UI-DEN-5751-1 01 Feb 2021

See the reply above.

UI-DEN-4598-1 03 Nov 2020

Done

UI-DEN-4598-1 03 Nov 2020

RESOLVED

UI-DEN-4598-1 03 Nov 2020

RESOLVED

HD-DEN-5674-2 29 Dec 2020

Macro starts with capital "M" for DialIn/DialOut but here with lower cap.

HD-DEN-5674-2 30 Dec 2020

we are (forma) instead of we're (informal)

UI-DEN-4598-1 09 Nov 2020

RESOLVED

HD-DEN-5674-2 30 Dec 2020

we have (formal) instead of we've (informal)

UI-DEN-4598-1 09 Nov 2020

RESOLVED

UI-DEN-4598-1 09 Nov 2020

RESOLVED

UI-DEN-4598-1 09 Nov 2020

RESOLVED

DG-DEN-5980-1 22 Feb 2021

Why is this commented out?

UI-DEN-4598-1 09 Nov 2020

RESOLVED

HD-DEN-4641-1 01 Dec 2020

Done.

UI-DEN-6349-1 12 Jan 2021

This file is now deleted

HD-DEN-4641-1 01 Dec 2020

Don't know. Changed to "" for consistency.

HD-DEN-4641-1 01 Dec 2020

Comment mentions blood, is not this *.c file related to dialysate out pump?

HD-DEN-4641-1 01 Dec 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

HD-DEN-4641-1 01 Dec 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

DG-DEN-5855-1 03 Dec 2020

Done

DG-DEN-5846-1 04 Dec 2020

Done

DIALIN-DIAL-23-1 12 Jan 2021

Is this an output that is generated from code or is this a list of alarms we maintain as input to the code?

DG-DEN-5864-1 07 Dec 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

UI-DEN-5830-2 12 Jan 2021

Same here.

UI-DEN-5830-2 12 Jan 2021

Shouldn't this be declared last?

DG-DEN-5873-1 07 Dec 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

UI-DEN-6349-1 08 Jan 2021

Why a simple name, address value set has been converted to a Jason Document by that complicated dereferencing and casting of pointers and passed over all the stacks of signal/slots instead of a simple struct?

DG-DEN-5846-1 07 Dec 2020

We need to move this check out of else condition and use the if condition. The persistent alarm check function need to be switching between true and false cases to work, otherwise we need to use windowed time count.

DG-DEN-5855-1 07 Dec 2020

If line needs to be commented, our process is to add a TODO as line comment so as not to forget to delete or modify this line down the road.

DG-DEN-5846-1 07 Dec 2020

align "(" on second line with the beginning of TEMPERATURE on right hand side of "=" sign, do the same with both lines 151 and 153.

DIALIN-DEN-4690-1 07 Oct 2020

The return types are missing for many functions in this file

DIALIN-DEN-4690-1 30 Sep 2020

A description is needed here in words of what this function does

DIALIN-DEN-4690-1 30 Sep 2020

This needs to be updated to use the DenaliCanMessenger instead of cansend

UI-DEN-4598-1 29 Oct 2020

After the Doxygeization effort, all the classes shall have the documentation with messaging information.
Please add to all your classes.
For example on how to do please refer to the Model/View classes.
And when doc generated it will also be used for SDD.
it should contain:

  • \brief
  • \details
  • Message information
  • Message Payload information as each field in a line (see example below)
  • \sa(see also) which has related classes to this class
  • Logging info which at least has 3 lines (see example below and follow the HTML syntax for formating in doxygen please.)


An example provided. please look at more examples for your specific case in the code on the master branch.

/*!
 * \brief   The MAdjustSalineResponse class
 * \details The Saline Bolus adjustment response model
 *
 * | MSG  | CAN ID | M.Box | Type | Ack | Src | Dest | Description           |
 * |:----:|:------:|:-----:|:----:|:---:|:---:|:----:|:---------------------:|
 * |0x1400| 0x020  | 6     | Rsp  | Y   | HD  | UI   | Saline Bolus Response |
 *
 * | Payload  ||
 * |          ||
 * | #1:(U32) | \ref Data::mAccepted |
 * | #2:(U32) | \ref Data::mReason   |
 * | #3:(U32) | \ref Data::mTarget   |
 *
 * \sa Data
 * \sa MAdjustSalineReq : Saline Bolus Request
 * \sa MTreatmentSaline : Saline Bolus Data
 *
 * <h2 class="groupheader">Logging info</h2>
 * |              ||
 * |              ||
 * | typeText     | Event        |
 * | unitText     | HD           |
 * | infoText     | AdjustSaline |
 *
 */
DG-DEN-5864-1 02 Dec 2020

This was a place holder. I fixed the arguments.