•  

Comment Results

Review Name Created Custom Fields Content
DG-DEN-3421-1 12 Aug 2020

Is the "\" necessary in C for the Compiler we use?

DG-DEN-3421-1 12 Aug 2020

We either add a "." or not at the end of each comment, but we need to be consistent in the way we do it.

DG-DEN-3421-1 12 Aug 2020

Sean Nash Could you please respond?

DG-DEN-4217-1 12 Aug 2020

Done

DG-DEN-3421-1 12 Aug 2020

Yes, I have seen issues if I don't put it.

DG-DEN-3421-1 12 Aug 2020

Yes, I have seen issues if I don't put it.

DG-DEN-3421-1 12 Aug 2020

Yes, I have seen issues if I don't put it.

DG-DEN-3421-1 12 Aug 2020

Sean Nash Could you please respond?

DG-DEN-3421-1 12 Aug 2020

All modules will have doxygen hooks eventually

DG-DEN-3421-1 12 Aug 2020

Done

DG-DEN-3421-1 12 Aug 2020

Done

DG-DEN-3421-1 12 Aug 2020

Will fix this in the code

DG-DEN-3421-1 13 Aug 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

DG-DEN-3421-1 12 Aug 2020

Where is the /*@}/ Doxygen comment at eof?

DG-DEN-3421-1 13 Aug 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

DG-DEN-3421-1 12 Aug 2020

One liner

DG-DEN-2379-1 20 May 2020

Should we just set this in initTemperatures() so we don't have to check for zero in this function?

DIALIN-DEN-4438-1 28 Aug 2020

RESOLVED

VV-DEN-1434-1 11 Jun 2020

Fixed. File is moved to a branch.

UI-DEN-3253-1 23 Jun 2020

RESOLVED

VV-DEN-1434-1 12 Jun 2020

RESOLVED.

DG-DEN-4217-1 17 Aug 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

UI-DEN-3149-1 23 Jun 2020

msg complete

UI-DEN-3253-1 17 Jun 2020

Dispositioned to DEN-3742

UI-DEN-3149-1 12 Jun 2020

Please remove, only files that are needed for the IDEs and builds should be part of the repos to keep them clean. You can use OneNoe, X;/ drive, OneDrive, and your local drive for storing personal TODO lists. The other option is to make TODO comments in the code.

UI-DEN-3149-1 11 Jun 2020

Typically, TODOs are handled by searching the entire codebase for the keyword "TODO" and list shall be reduced to 0 count before any formal release. What is this additional list of TODOs for?

UI-DEN-3253-1 01 Jul 2020

Done

UI-DEN-3149-1 14 Jun 2020

Thanks for catching again.
The spellchecker has been stopped working and I can't make it run again.
Corrected.

DG-DEN-4217-1 17 Aug 2020

Planned to be taken care of in DEN S26.

UI-DEN-3149-1 15 Jun 2020

I took a look at the current C++ coding standard, here: X:\Engineering\Denali\06- Software Design\Software Documentation\Coding Standards, but the section on Macros is lacking. Therefore, I consulting an outside coding standard, called C++ Coding Standards 101 Rules, Guidelines, and Best Practices by Herb Sutter and Andrei Alexandrescu. Chapter 16 of this book is entitled “Avoid macros.” There is a quote in this book from Bjarne Stroustrup, creator of the C++ programming language:

“Macros are almost never necessary in C+…”
“…The first rule about macros is: Don’t use them unless you have to. Almost every macro demonstrates a flaw in the programming language, in the program or in the programmer.”

Additionally, the authors of the book have these comments on macros:

“An error in a macro can only be reported after the macro is expanded and not when it is defined.”
“Always given them SCREAMING_UPPERCASE_AND_UGLY names, and avoid putting them in headers”

If the creator of C
+ says don’t use macros unless you have to, I think we should use them sparingly. Each time one of these macros is used in a .h or .cpp file, you have to come back to main.h and deduce the generated code from 2+ layers of macro indirection. This I am sure is very hurtful to the readability of the code. Our coding standard encourages readability, and so I think it is in the spirit of it to limit the use of macros as much as possible.

DG-DEN-3421-1 12 Aug 2020

Done

UI-DEN-3253-1 17 Jun 2020

Requested change has been made. Ready to be resolved

DG-DEN-3922-1 21 Jul 2020

Done

UI-DEN-3253-1 01 Jul 2020

Also there are two icons in NotificationBar.qml, the alert icon and the alarm silence icon. The small notification bar only has one icon

HD-DEN-3115-1 19 Jun 2020

This is where I am changing the default IRQ priorities to what I want.

UI-DEN-3253-1 01 Jul 2020

It needs to be separated at least for now because the icon placement is different now that we are putting the alarm silence icon at the very left of the alarm bar. The small notification bar, which is primarily used inside alerts instead of alarms, does not have alarm specific functions and animation needed for high priority alarms.

DG-DEN-4217-1 17 Aug 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

HD-DEN-3115-1 19 Jun 2020

This is the TI copyright that we got these API files originally. Yes, they are different from the other TI files that are generated by HALCoGen but they are still TI files and not ours. When I was working on the copyright script, I realized the script did not realize they are not our files and added our copyright. I enhanced the algorithm that checks whether a file belongs to Diality or not, so this issue will not happen. At the same time, I removed the Diality copyright. I am not sure why there is a "?" in their copyright that does not affect the script's parsing capabilities.

DG-DEN-4217-1 12 Aug 2020

Only one space between ) and // comment.

HD-DEN-3115-1 19 Jun 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

DIALIN-DEN-2379-1 09 Jul 2020

RESOLVED.

HD-DEN-3115-1 19 Jun 2020

RESOLVED in CODE WALKTHROUGH.

DG-DEN-3922-1 21 Jul 2020

Done

DIALIN-DEN-3593-1 20 Jul 2020

Done

DIALIN-DEN-3593-1 20 Jul 2020

Done

DG-DEN-3922-1 21 Jul 2020

Done

DIALIN-DEN-3593-1 20 Jul 2020

RESOLVED.

UI-DEN-4438-1 25 Aug 2020

removed extra line.

DIALIN-DEN-3593-1 20 Jul 2020

RESOLVED.

DG-DEN-3922-1 21 Jul 2020

Used build switch to handle DG vs. HD.